Internet Archive's digital book lending violates copyright, US judge rules

Internet Archive's digital book lending violates copyright, US judge rules

A federal judge determined that the Internet Archive infringed copyright by scanning and digitally lending protected books from major publishers, rejecting the organization’s claim that its actions constituted fair use. The ruling establishes that while owning physical copies allows for lending, bulk digitization without licensing does not, as these digital copies effectively replace traditional library licenses. This decision highlights the legal tension between expanding digital access to information and protecting intellectual property rights in the modern era. By denying fair use protection, the court prioritizes the economic interests of authors and publishers, signaling that widespread digital replication without permission remains unlawful despite the nonprofit’s educational mission. For the open data community, this case illustrates the fragility of digital preservation efforts when they intersect with copyrighted content. It underscores the necessity of clear licensing frameworks and legal safeguards to ensure that historical records and knowledge remain accessible without violating existing copyright laws, emphasizing the need for careful compliance in digital archiving projects.

Source: digbycourier.ca
Published on 2026-11-15