INDECOPI and the debate on originality and copyright

INDECOPI and the debate on originality and copyright

The article addresses the tension between the subjectivity inherent in originality and the need for objective criteria to grant legal protection. It concludes that, although authorship reflects the creator’s personality, the law requires perceptible manifestations that distinguish original expression from mere reproduction or mechanical effort, emphasizing that the labor invested does not automatically confer copyright. In the context of generative artificial intelligence, it is stressed that algorithmic automation does not equate to human authorship. To assert rights, users must demonstrate significant creative intervention and substantial control over the output, ensuring that the final work bears a personal imprint and genuine expressive choices, going beyond the mere instruction of the system. This reflection is fundamental to open data, as it establishes precedents regarding the ownership and protection of digital assets. In open data environments, where automated processing is common, clearly defining what constitutes a “human creation” versus an “algorithmic output” is crucial to ensuring transparency, proper attribution, and the legitimacy of intellectual property rights over datasets and their derivatives.

Source: jornada.com.pe
Published on 2026-11-18